Feelings are not God

This may be a bit controversial, a therapist writing an article that reprimands the authority we give to our feelings. After all, isn’t “How does that make you feel?” The ultimate therapy question? I have absolutely asked clients that question, but I am not asking because I believe their feelings should be their guide. Actually, I am asking to understand how they are perceiving the information that they are sharing. Feelings can give us incredibly valuable information. They can tell us what we fear, what we value, what has hurt us, and how we are interpreting the circumstances around us. But there is a significant difference between listening to our feelings and allowing our feelings to define truth.

If you have spent any time on my couch you have probably heard me share some version of one of my favorite quotes from theologian John Piper:

“My feelings are not God. God is God. My feelings do not define truth. God’s word defines truth. My feelings are echoes and responses to what my mind perceives. And sometimes—many times—my feelings are out of sync with the truth.”

John Piper

When feelings are out of line, the Christian response cannot be to bend the truth until it accommodates how we feel. Instead, we have to be willing to bring our perceptions, thoughts, and feelings before the Lord and allow His truth to correct us.

According to the Cognitive Behavioral Therapy approach, our thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are interconnected. The way we interpret a situation influences how we feel, and those feelings can then influence how we behave. If I believe my friend intentionally excluded me, for example, I may feel hurt or rejected. If I sit in that feeling and continue telling myself the story I have created about why she excluded me, that hurt can become resentment. And if resentment is allowed to take over, it is eventually going to show up in the way I interact with her. I may withdraw, become passive-aggressive, say something unkind, or begin building a case against her in my mind. This is why allowing our feelings unchecked authority is not harmless. Our thoughts influence our feelings, our feelings influence our behavior, and our behavior can lead us toward either righteousness or sin.

Sometimes the problem is simply that our feelings are based on a misunderstanding. Think about how quickly a conversation can go sideways because of a text message. Imagine your husband sends you a message that says, “I love you, Barb.”… Your name isn’t Barb. Suddenly your heart drops, your stomach turns, and your brain begins conducting a full-scale investigation. Who is Barb? Why does he love Barb? How long has this been going on? Before you know it, you are searching Facebook for every Barb within a thirty-mile radius while your husband is frantically trying to explain that autocorrect betrayed him. “…Babs*…Bass*…BABE** BABE** I was trying to say BABE!!**”

Too late. If your feelings are running the show, this poor man just received a 20-yard penalty straight to the couch for the night.

The anger is real. The hurt is real. The suspicion is real. But the conclusion may be completely wrong. We do much more serious versions of this all the time. We can interpret someone’s silence as rejection, someone’s correction as criticism, or someone’s bad mood as evidence that they are angry with us. We can take a temporary circumstance and turn it into a permanent conclusion. We can feel unloved and conclude that we are unloved, feel rejected and conclude that we have been rejected, or feel like we cannot handle something and decide that we truly cannot. Feelings are real, but they are not necessarily an accurate interpretation of our reality. And that distinction becomes especially important when the feeling itself is revealing something sinful in us.

Maybe your friend is asked to lead the women’s event at church. You genuinely wanted the opportunity, so when someone else gets it, you feel slighted. You think, What about me? Why didn’t they ask me? That feeling may be very real, but it does not automatically make it holy. In fact, it may be revealing jealousy, pride, insecurity, or selfish ambition. And if we simply assume that every feeling deserves to be honored, that little “What about me?” can become resentment, bitterness, and envy before we even realize what has happened.

Before long, something that began as a fleeting emotional response has become a pattern of sinful thinking and we no longer recognize ourselves. Scripture tells us to take every thought captive to obey Christ (2 Corinthians 10:5), and that means we don’t simply let every thought or feeling set up camp in our minds. We bring it before the Lord. We ask Him to search us and expose what is sinful. We confess it and ask Him to change us. Instead of feeding our jealousy, we can pray for our friend, intercede for her, and genuinely rejoice that God is using another flawed sinner, just as He graciously chooses to use us, to advance His kingdom and glorify Himself. That may not be what we initially feel like doing, but sanctification is not measured by whether everything we feel is comfortable or convenient. It is measured by whether we are becoming more obedient to Christ.

We are called to bring our feelings before the Lord and allow His truth to correct, transform, and ultimately reshape us. That may sound harsh in a culture that has made feelings increasingly authoritative. We are told to “follow your heart,” “trust your gut,” “do what feels right,” and, of course, “if it makes you happy, do it.” But Scripture gives us a very different warning:

There is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way to death.

Proverbs 14:12

Something can seem right and still be wrong. Something can feel right and still lead somewhere destructive. Our feelings can be useful indicators, but they are poor masters.

Scripture gives us something far more stable. Proverbs 9:10 says, “The fear of the LORD is the beginning of wisdom.” Wisdom begins with recognizing who God is. God is God, and I am not. My feelings are not the highest authority in my life because I am not the highest authority in my life. God is. And His Word is truth. Jesus prayed in John 17:17, “Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth.” Scripture is not simply something to consult when I want encouragement or reassurance. It is the foundation on which I build my life. It tells me what is true about God, about myself, about sin, about relationships, about suffering, and about how I am called to live. That means there will be times when God’s Word comforts my feelings, but there will also be times when it confronts them.

Perhaps you have experienced extreme heartache, grief, trauma, or suffering. Maybe you feel like giving up but God calls you to trust Him to help you persevere. It is important to make clear that Christianity does not teach us to ignore or suppress our emotions. God cares about our feelings. Scripture gives us example after example of people bringing their most raw emotions directly to Him. Lamentations is full of grief and anguish. Job cries out in the middle of devastating suffering and confusion. David’s Psalms are filled with fear, anger, despair, joy, gratitude, doubt, and hope. These people were not condemned for having emotions. They were bringing those emotions into relationship with God.

First Peter 5:7 tells us to cast all our anxieties on Him because He cares for us. God does not tell us to get our emotions together before we come to Him. He invites us to bring them to Him precisely because He cares. The message here is not that our emotions are bad, nor that grief, heartache, fear, or suffering should simply be ignored. Quite the opposite. The message is that our emotions are not Lord over our lives, and they are not meant to become our safe place to hide. Christ is. Perhaps you have suffered a devastating loss. Perhaps you are grieving something that cannot simply be fixed with a Bible verse and a better attitude. I am by no means suggesting that you should ignore that grief or pretend that your heart is not broken. Scripture certainly does not ask us to do that. It invites us to bring our deepest pain to God and take refuge in Him. Psalm 61:4 says, “Let me dwell in your tent forever! Let me take refuge under the shelter of your wings!” What a beautiful picture of what we are being called to do with our emotions. We don’t deny the grief, trauma, or heartache, we bring it under the shelter of the Almighty. Our feelings can be brought into the presence of Christ without being placed on the throne of our lives. This is not a charge to stop feeling. It is a charge to make our feelings submitted and surrendered to our Savior.

There is perhaps no clearer picture of this than Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane. Jesus knew what was coming. He knew He was about to be betrayed, beaten, mocked, tortured, and crucified. He knew the suffering that awaited Him, and He did not pretend it was easy. He told His disciples, “My soul is very sorrowful, even to death” (Matthew 26:38). Luke tells us that His anguish was so great that His sweat became like great drops of blood falling to the ground (Luke 22:44).

Jesus felt anguish. He did not deny it. He brought it honestly before His Father and asked, “Father, if you are willing, remove this cup from me.” But He did not stop there. He surrendered His feelings and His desires to the Father’s will:

Nevertheless, not my will, but yours, be done.

Luke 22:42

Jesus did not allow the very real emotions of the moment to dictate His next steps. He submitted them to the will of the Father. And it is difficult to overstate the significance of that obedience. Imagine if Jesus had obeyed His feelings rather than the Father’s will. This is too painful. I don’t want to do this. I deserve something different. I am going to do what feels right for me. There would be no cross, no resurrection, and no salvation. No hope for all of humanity. The anguish did not overrule the eternal will of God.

And neither should mine.

That does not mean I cannot be afraid. It does not mean I cannot grieve. It does not mean I cannot be angry, disappointed, jealous, or overwhelmed. It means that those feelings are brought under the authority of Christ. I can be terrified and still obey. I can be heartbroken and still trust. I can feel overlooked and still celebrate someone else. I can feel jealous and still pray for the person I envy. I can be deeply unhappy in a particular season without assuming that my unhappiness gives me permission to abandon what God has called me to do.

Romans 12:2 tells us to be transformed by the renewing of our minds, and that transformation should eventually reach every part of us—including the way we think, desire, and respond. Psalm 119:105 tells us that God’s Word is a lamp to our feet and a light to our path. Sometimes that light will comfort us. Sometimes it will expose something in us that we would rather not see. Sometimes it will show us that what we called “peace” was actually avoidance, or that what we called “following our heart” was actually following our flesh.

Feelings are fleeting and change with my circumstances, my assumptions, my experiences, my exhaustion, and sometimes my sin. God’s truth does not. His wisdom is greater than mine, His will is better than my plans, and His perspective is infinitely more trustworthy than my own.

So yes, as a therapist, I care about feelings. I listen to them. I take them seriously. I want to understand what they are telling us about the way we perceive our circumstances and the beliefs underneath those perceptions. But I do not believe that every feeling is true, and I certainly do not believe that every feeling deserves to determine what we do.

As I said before, feelings are valuable indicators, but they are terrible masters. They do not get to define the truth or take control. Otherwise, we can end up flying down the freeway of life like a crazed maniac with a busted-out headlight and a bumper dragging along the pavement, sparks flying behind us, having already hit every mile marker and guardrail along the way. Eventually, something is going to crash. JESUS TAKE THE WHEEL!

My feelings are welcome in the presence of God. I can bring Him my anger, my fear, my grief, my confusion, my disappointment, and my joy. I don’t have to hide any of it from Him. But I don’t have to worship my feelings. I don’t have to obey them. And I don’t have to bend God’s truth to make my feelings more comfortable. Instead, I can pray the words of John Piper:

Purify my perceptions of your truth and transform my feelings so that they are in sync with the truth.

Because my feelings are not God.

God is God.

Every path at Banner begins the same way: a free 20-minute conversation with our Care Coordinator — where you are right now, what you’re oriented toward, and what a good next step looks like.

Speak with our Care Coordinator

Or call 318.396.8152